Troubling questions on a wrenching video

New Delhi: Adjectives cannot convey the horror of what’s happened in Manipur. It’s beyond description. Instead, it’s been seared into our conscience like the dreadful Nirbhaya rape a decade ago. But the May 4th rapes are only one deplorable instance. From two different sources we know there are perhaps five more.

For days to come our attention will be riveted on the gruesome details. Indeed, I fear there is worse to follow. However, today let me focus on some of the questions raised by the official response to the May 4th incident. They’re also disturbing.

The younger of the two women has told the Indian Express: “The police were there with the mob which was attacking our village.” Does that mean our supposed protectors stood by and watched like spectators? She adds: “We were given to them (the mob) by the police.” Does this mean, even if outnumbered, the police weakly surrendered? They certainly did not defend the women at the cost of their own safety and lives. But isn’t that what we would have expected?

After handing over the women, how come the police did not summon additional forces? Should that not have been the obvious and immediate response? Not only did that not happen, the women were left to walk seven kilometers to the nearest hospital. At least, at this point, the police could have been man enough to reappear and help?

Now, the first FIR was registered on 18th May. The second on 21st June. But the police say they couldn’t act because they did not have evidence and couldn’t identify the perpetrators. Really? Could they not identify the men they handed the women to? Did they forget their faces? The younger woman has told the Express she recognized some members of the mob, including a friend of her brother’s. Was that not sufficient? The truth is even till today the police have not recorded the women’s statements.

Let’s move on. Chief Minister Biren Singh claims he took “suo moto” cognizance of this case when he saw the video. Suo moto? The FIR was first filed two months ago.

The Chairperson of the National Commission for Women (NCW) has revealed she informed Manipur’s Chief Secretary (CS) and Director General of Police (DGP) of this incident on 19th June. Did no one tell the Chief Minister? And what about the CS and DGP? Why did they not act?

One more point. For two months the authorities claim they couldn’t act because they couldn’t identify the perpetrators. In the next 24 hours they arrested four. Is that a response at the speed of summer lightening or yet another question that needs an answer?

Finally, let’s come to the NCW. On 12th June it received a letter from the North American Manipur Tribal Association and two Manipuri women activists which said: “On May 4th, two women from B. Phainom village of Kangpokpi district of Manipur were disrobed, paraded naked, beaten, and then encircled by a marauding Meitei mob and raped in public. The state police commandoes remained mere spectators … the two survivors are housed at a Churachandpur district relief camp.” I’d say that’s pretty specific and detailed.

However, Rekha Sharma, the NCW Chairperson, says she couldn’t act because the information was “generic … and not just one specific incident”. She also claims the Commission couldn’t send a delegation because of the situation in Manipur. Yet Rahul Gandhi was able to visit. Also women social activists led by Annie Raja. But not the intrepid Commission.

However, give her her due, Sharma did write to the CS and DGP. They did nothing and she didn’t bother. Does this mean she did the bare minimum required or is even that disputable?

Let me end with one of the comments politicians make when they little realize it might boomerang. In 2017, when Congress was in power, the Prime Minister tweeted: “Those who cannot ensure peace in the state have no right to govern Manipur.” I wouldn’t quarrel with that.

( The views expresed by the author in this article are his personal )

 

INDIA NEWS STREAM

The rocky neighbourhood for India to negotiate

New Delhi: For India, diplomatically and otherwise, the past two months have been particularly difficult in the neighbourhood, with tensions escalating on its western and eastern borders, with its two...

Israeli PM Netanyahu reaffirms to fully control Gaza; dismisses speculation of rift with Trump

Jerusalem: Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has reaffirmed his government's intention to fully reoccupy besieged Gaza, dismissed any agreement to end the war, and brushed aside any speculations of a...

Bangladesh: Yunus regime backtracks on providing ‘Humanitarian Corridor’ to Myanmar

Dhaka: Bangladesh's National Security Advisor Khalilur Rahman on Wednesday ruled out any possibility of allowing a corridor through Bangladesh for Myanmar, saying the government led by Muhammad Yunus has neither...

‘All-party delegations not needed’: Shiv Sena-UBT stirs fresh row

Mumbai: Shiv Sena-UBT leader Ambadas Danve has sparked a fresh political row by stating that the all-party delegations were "not needed" for India’s global outreach on cross-border terrorism. The remarks...

Operation Sindoor Outreach: First group of All Party Delegation leaves for five-nation tour

New Delhi: India on Wednesday rolled out its massive global campaign 'Operation Sindoor Outreach' to expose Pakistan's direct and indirect links to terrorism as the first group of an all-party...

UN chief calls for efforts to address root causes of maritime insecurity

United Nations: UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres stressed the need to intensify efforts to address the root causes of maritime insecurity. "Threats to maritime security cannot be addressed without also addressing...

Britain suspends trade negotiations with Israel over Gaza aid blockade

London: British Foreign Secretary David Lammy announced on Tuesday that Britain has suspended trade negotiations with Israel over its Gaza blockade. Lammy also said the Israeli ambassador had been summoned....

UK-EU ties reset with new bilateral deal

London: Britain and the European Union (EU) reached a wide-ranging agreement, which is expected to generate nearly 9 billion pounds (about $12.02 billion) for the British economy by 2040, Downing...

‘Not consulted’: Abhishek Banerjee on Trinamool’s decision to withdraw Yusuf Pathan from ‘Operation Sindoor’ delegations

Kolkata: Trinamool Congress General Secretary Abhishek Banerjee on Monday spoke out on his party's decision to withdraw the name of cricketer-turned-politician Yusuf Pathan from the multi-party MPs delegations on Operation...

Trinamool withdrew name from Op Sindoor delegation as Mamata Banerjee not consulted

Kolkata: The Centre's action of selecting and including Yusuf Pathan, the cricketer-turned-politician and Lok Sabha member from Baharampur constituency of West Bengal, in the multi-party delegation on Operation Sindoor without...

IMF slaps 11 more conditions on Pakistan, flags tensions with India as big risk

New Delhi,: The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has slapped 11 new conditions on Pakistan for the $ 7 billion lifeline that it has extended and also flagged the rising tensions...

Russia’s growing outreach in South Asia manifestation of its non-coercive diplomacy

New Delhi: Russia is making concerted efforts to underscore its position as a global power. It has stepped up engagements with the Global South, including South Asia. Trade and economic...

Read Previous

Assam Rifles files sedition case against Manipur civil society body

Read Next

2 Delhi traffic cops suspended after Korean YouTuber uploads video of them extorting Rs 5K

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com