CAA-NRC new source of tension with India; should be sorted out, says former Bangladesh diplomat

From Left:Former diplomat of Bangladesh Ambassador Munshi Faiz Ahmad, former foreign secretary Kanwal Sibal, IDSA DG
Ambassador Sujan R Chenoy, Bhutan’s Ambassador to India General Vetsop Namgyel and former Afghan Ambassador to India Shaida Mohammad Abdali.

Jan 28, 2020

New Delhi: A very senior former diplomat of Bangladesh and also former chairman of a leading government think tank of his country Ambassador Munshi Faiz Ahmad on Tuesday described the controversial Citizenship Amendment Act(CAA) and the National Register of Citizens(NRC) and as a new source of tension between the two neighbours that have the ”best of relations”.

He expressed concern over the ”less than friendly pronouncements from senoior Indian ministers and leaders” on the CAA-NRC, but also noted that there were lot of voices inside India that shared Bangladesh’s concern.

Ambassador Ahmad, who has headed the prestigious Government think tank Bangladesh Institute of International and Strategic Studies, Dhaka’, was speaking at a seminar on ‘India’s Neighbourhood First Policy: Regional Perceptions’ organised by the Indian Institute of Defence Studies and Analysis here.

He said people from Bangladesh were brought to Assam even before partition to work in tea gardens to boost the economy of the state, and that way migrations have helped the countries.

The former diplomat regreted that ”now people were being pushed away”, and underscored that creating hatred and division among the people will not help either of the countries.

He urged the leaders of the two sides sit down and sort out the issue in the interest of ”best of relations that exist between India and Bangladesh.”

He also expressed concern over Bangladeshi people getting killed by the BSF on the border, which he termed as another major source of tension between the two countries.

Ahmad, a former ambassador to China, also urged India not to be ”hyper sensitive” to Chinese influence in Bangladesh, which he said was creating problem.

Though the two countries were very friendly neighbours, but still there was some trust deficit, so India should take the lead in removing it, and other countries should also do due deligence, he said, adding that India should not be seen as hinderance to neighbours cultivating diverse relationships.

He also asserted that that the paranoia about China was based on a myth.”I dont think that Beijing poses a threat to its neighbours outside South China Sea.

However, Ahmad’s views on China were hotly contested by Ditector General of IDSA Ambassador Sujan R Chenoy and former foreign secretary Kanwal Sibal. Amb Chenoy said India was not paranoid about China and it itself was seeking good relations with Beijing. China had grown very largely in every respect, and there was no transparency about its intentions, so it should engage India and other neighbours about its expanding influence like in the Indian Ocean, and about CPEC which has not happened.

Sibal also said that it would be very simplicistic to conclude that China had benign intentions. ”Our concern is the increasing Chinese infulence in the Bay of Bengal,” he said, adding that instead of India being hyper sensitive, it was China that was hyper-paranid about Tibet, Taiwan, Article 370.

Former Afghan Ambassador to India Shaida Mohammad Abdali and Bhutan’s envoy to India General Vetsop Namgyel were among the distinguished panelist in the first session of the seminar held as part of the the 12th South Asia Conference which was earlier inaugurated by Defence Minister Rajnath Singh.

The Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses has been holding the annual since 2007. The event brings together policy makers, academics, and professionals from the South Asian region to discuss issues of common interest.

–India News Stream

Pakistan welcomes Trump’s willingness to ‘mediate’ on Kashmir

Islamabad: Pakistan on Sunday welcomed US President Donald Trump's "constructive role" in brokering a ceasefire understanding between Islamabad and New Delhi. In a statement issued by Pakistan's foreign office, Islamabad...

Trump offers to mediate Kashmir solution after announcing India-Pakistan ceasefire

Washington: US President Donald Trump on Sunday expressed willingness to mediate a resolution to the decades-old Kashmir dispute between India and Pakistan, sarcastically terming it a conflict of "a thousand...

‘War is not India’s choice’: NSA Doval speaks to Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi amid India-Pak tensions

New Delhi: In a high-level diplomatic exchange, Indian National Security Advisor (NSA) Ajit Doval on Saturday held a telephonic conversation with Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi and reaffirmed that "war...

US Secretary of State dials India, Pakistan counterparts on escalating tensions

Washington: US Secretary of State Marco Rubio on Saturday (Indian time) spoke to External Affairs Minister (EAM) S. Jaishankar, calling to de-escalate tensions at the India-Pakistan border, and offered US...

Recall real aggressor, India tells Afghans as it rebuts Pak’s claims of missile hitting Afghanistan

New Delhi: Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri on Saturday firmly rejected Pakistan's "ludicrous claims" that Indian missiles had hit Afghanistan, calling them "totally frivolous allegations." Speaking at a Press conference alongside...

If this escalates further, nobody wins: UK Foreign Secy after speaking with EAM Jaishankar, Pak Foreign Minister

London/New Delhi: External Affairs Minister (EAM) S. Jaishankar on Friday held a telephonic conversation with the UK Foreign Secretary David Lammy as both leaders discussed combatting terrorism with a zero...

India adhered to Indus Waters Treaty for 65 years despite so many provocations from Pakistan: MEA

New Delhi: Slamming the disinformation being spread by Pakistan on the suspension of the Indus Waters Treaty (IWT) following the horrific terror attack in Pahalgam on April 22 which resulted...

Trump offers ‘help’ to stop tensions escalate between India and Pakistan

Washington: Amid escalating tensions with Pakistan after India launched airstrike on terror launchpads in Pakistan and Pakistan Occupied Kashmir, US President Donald Trump has expressed concerns and said that "he...

Iran FM Araghchi arrives in Delhi amid growing India-Pak tensions

New Delhi: Iranian Foreign Minister Seyed Abbas Araghchi arrived in New Delhi on Thursday to co-chair the 20th India-Iran Joint Commission Meeting with External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar. Araghchi's visit...

EAM Jaishankar dials counterparts in Asia and Europe, discusses strikes on Pak-based terror camps

New Delhi: External Affairs Minister (EAM) S. Jaishankar on Wednesday spoke with the foreign ministers of Japan, Qatar, Spain, France and Germany, discussing India's strikes on Pakistan-based terror camps earlier...

PM Modi cancels Europe visit amid heightened tensions with Pakistan

New Delhi: Prime Minister Narendra Modi has called off his scheduled three-nation Europe tour in the wake of heightened tensions with Pakistan, sources confirmed on Wednesday. PM Modi was scheduled...

Pahalgam attack aimed to derail J&K’s normalcy, foster Pak’s cross-border terrorism, says India

New Delhi: Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri on Wednesday said the April 22 Pahalgam terror attack was a calculated attempt to disrupt the return of normalcy in Jammu and Kashmir and...

Read Previous

Demonstrators display placards during their protest against CAA and NRC, in Lucknow on Tuesday. (ANI Photo)

Read Next

Reflection on partition as government opens wounds on citizenship

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com