‘Can’t declare minorities at district level’, SC on plea seeking minority status for Hindus


New Delhi, Aug 8: The Supreme Court on Monday reiterated that religious and linguistic minority status has to be decided state-wise, and orally observed that it is difficult to entertain a prayer to identify religious and linguistic minorities at the district level.


A bench headed by justice U.U. Lalit expressed its reservation to entertain a plea seeking to declare Hindus as minority in states where they are out-numbered by other communities.


The bench, also comprising justice S Ravindra Bhat, pointed out to a counsel representing the petitioner that previously it had asked senior advocate Arvind Datar, who was appearing for the petitioner then, to produce concrete examples where Hindus are being denied the benefits of minority status in states where they are numerically less.


Advocate Ashwini Upadhyay, who filed another similar petition in the matter, submitted before the bench that Hindus are minorities in some states. The bench replied, “Theoretically you’re right, but if the Supreme Court has said it had to be state-wise, why should we interfere?”


It may be noted that in the case of TMA Pai and others vs State of Karnataka (2002), the Supreme Court had held that minorities must be identified at the state-level.


Upadhyay had also filed a petition challenging the provisions of National Commission for Minorities Act 1992 and National Commission for Minority Educational Institutions Act 2004 and sought minority status for Hindus in certain states/UTs.


The bench noted that when it is talking about minorities, there are all India minorities, for example, there are Parsis and Konkani speaking people and there are people who are minorities in a small place. It further queried the counsel, “so how do you declare? It is not the job of the court to declare”.


The bench told the counsel that it is generally saying that Hindus must be declared as minority, which the court cannot declare due to absence of statistics for every particular state and every particular religion.


The top court reiterated its query and asked the counsel to give concrete examples of cases where Hindus are denied the protection of Article 30 in states where they are in a minority.


After hearing the arguments, the bench scheduled the hearing in the first week of September.


The top court was hearing a plea filed by Devkinandan Thakur, challenging a provision of the National Commission for Minorities (NCM) Act and seeking a direction to the Centre to define “minority” and lay down the guidelines for the identification of minorities at the district level.


The plea said: “Cause of action continues till date because followers of Judaism, Bahaism, and Hinduism; who are real minorities in Ladakh, Mizoram, Lakshadweep, Kashmir, Nagaland, Meghalaya, Arunachal Pradesh, Punjab, Manipur, cannot establish and administer educational institutions of their choice because of non-identification of �minority’ at the state level, thus jeopardising their basic rights guaranteed under Article 29-30″.


The plea contended that their right under Articles 29-30 is being siphoned off illegally to the majority community in the state because the Centre has not notified them as �minority’ under the NCM Act.


The plea challenged the Section 2(C) of the Act, which declared Muslims, Christians, Buddhists, Parsis, Sikhs and Jains as minorities at the national level and sought direction for district-wise identification of minorities and state-wise status.


In May this year, the Ministry of Minority Affairs had told the Supreme Court that though the power is vested with the Centre to notify minorities, there should be a wider consultation with states and other stakeholders in view of the plea seeking a direction to the Centre to lay down guidelines for identification of minority at the state level, stating the Hindus are in minority in 10 states.


Women’s Reservation Bill gets President’s assent, becomes law

New Delhi: President Droupadi Murmu has given her assent to the Women's Reservation Bill, a week after it was passed by both Houses of Parliament, thus making it a law....

ISKCON sends Rs 100 cr defamation notice to BJP MP Maneka Gandhi

New Delhi: Days after BJP MP and former Union Minister Maneka Gandhi stirred a major controversy with her remarks that the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) is the "biggest...

SC grants bail to 75-yr-old man convicted after 40 years in murder & rape case

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has come to the rescue of a 75-year-old man who was convicted after 40 years in a 1983 murder and rape case. In its recent...

Allahabad HC asks UP govt to decide on sex change issue by Oct 18

Prayagraj: The Allahabad High Court has expressed dissatisfaction over the Uttar Pradesh government not framing guidelines as per the 2014 Supreme Court judgment that recognised transgender individuals as the ‘third...

‘Senior bureaucrats not listening’: Delhi govt seeks urgent hearing against Services Act in SC

New Delhi: The Delhi government on Wednesday told the Supreme Court that senior bureaucrats were not carrying out orders of the elected government while urging for an urgent hearing on...

26/11 case: Mumbai court to take up fresh charge sheet against terror accused Rana

Mumbai: Five months after a US court ordered the extradition of Pakistani-Canadian businessman Tahawwur Hussain Rana to India for his connections in the Mumbai 26/11 terror attacks, the city police...

Student slap case: ‘Incident should shock the conscience of state’, observes SC

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Monday orally remarked that the incident in Uttar Pradesh's Muzaffarnagar should "shock the conscience of the state” if the viral video of a school...

Judiciary, legal fraternity have been long protectors of India’s justice system: PM Modi

New Delhi: Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday said the legal fraternity plays a key role in the building of any country, adding that the judiciary and bar have long...

This is the original copy of Constitution: Meghwal on ‘secular, socialist’ words missing

New Delhi: Trashing the Opposition's allegations that the words "socialist, secular" are missing in the new copies of the Constitution, the Centre on Wednesday asserted that it was the copy...

Women Reservation Bill: Confusion regarding bill in tab; Shah seen explaining to Rajnath, Owaisi helps SP MP

New Delhi: As part of the proceedings on the first day in the new Parliament complex, the Narendra Modi government introduced the much awaited Women Reservation Bill. While Union Law...

Centre introduces ‘Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam’ in Lok Sabha

New Delhi: The Centre on Tuesday introduced in Lok Sabha the 'Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam 2023' or the Women Reservation Bill, which seeks to guarantee 33 per cent quota for...

SC refuses to urgently list plea seeking legal action against Stalin Jr over his controversial statements on ‘Sanatan Dharma’

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Friday refused to pass any orders directing urgent listing of a plea seeking directions to Tamil Nadu government to register FIR against its minister...

Read Previous

Man arrested from Batla House for alleged IS links sent to NIA custody till Aug 16

Read Next

Israel and Palestine reach fragile truce

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com