The fine lines of India’s eastern, western borders

The pandemic was a great opportunity to read but, sadly, many books published during those dark days haven’t got the attention they deserve. Avtar Singh Bhasin’s ‘Nehru, Tibet and China’ is a prime example. It raises disturbing questions about India’s stand on both the eastern and western border with China and suggests Jawaharlal Nehru’s handling of this issue was almost irresponsible. After thirty years as Head of the Historical Division of the Ministry of External Affairs, Bhasin’s arguments are difficult to dispute, particularly when he’s corralled a mass of facts in support. Let me, briefly, share what he reveals.

From British times till 1954, Survey of India maps showed the western border as undefined. When Nehru decided a firm boundary must be marked he chose to unilaterally include the whole of Aksai Chin without any reason for believing the Chinese would accept. Two former Foreign Secretaries demurred. R. K. Nehru said: “Our experts had advised us that our claim to Aksai Chin was not too strong.” Subimal Dutt said the western boundary was not “properly delimited”.

However, Nehru insisted the boundary is “defined chiefly by long usage and custom”. Bhasin reveals there was no proof of this.

Worse, after claiming Aksai Chin India failed to assert its presence. Bhasin writes: “India even after having altered the border in 1954 had taken no steps to establish its military, political or administrative presence in the area … no check-post had been set up; no flag was unfurled to announce its sovereignty. India thought that merely drawing a line on the map was enough to announce its ownership.”

Worst of all, China built a 120 km road and during the seven years this was happening India was unaware of its existence. In 1957, when India found out, the protest was only informal. More bizarrely, it complained the Chinese men who built the road had not obtained Indian visas! Then, almost ludicrously, asked for Chinese help locating Indians who had gone missing on patrol duty. When the Chinese said they would deport them, India’s response was further damaging: “The question whether this particular area is in Indian or Chinese territory is a matter in dispute which is to be dealt with separately”. That confirmed doubts about India’s Aksai Chin claim.

Now, the eastern border. Here India’s claim is based on the validity of the 1914 McMahon Line. China, however, was not a party to the Simla Convention and never accepted this Line. That’s true both of the Kuomintang and Communist governments. Nehru knew this.

In 1935 McMahon himself questioned the 1914 Line. He called it a “verbal definition of the boundaries between Tibet and India”. Bhasin says this means the McMahon Line was drawn “on a map without surveys and was not delineated … it needed to be surveyed, delineated and demarcated”.

Here four facts are important. First, the British never occupied all the territory between the northern eastern border of that time and the McMahon Line. Second, Tibet remained in occupation of Tawang even though, according to McMahon, it was part of India. Third, Tibet wanted the McMahon Line adjusted to return “indisputable Tibetan territories that had been included in India”. Fourth, the British indicated a willingness to do this. Doesn’t this suggest the McMahon Line wasn’t sacrosanct?

In fact, Tawang remained in Tibetan hands till 1951.India only occupied it after Tibet began to fall under Chinese control, because if Tawang remained Tibetan it would become Chinese and, as Bhasin puts it, India’s border “would come down to the plains of Assam”.

Finally, Bhasin’s conclusion: “The Prime Minister had taken a simplistic view of the frontiers … Nehru’s insistence that India’s borders were what they were, maps or no maps, was unsustainable and proved disastrous for him and the nation.”

These are deeply disturbing findings and they clearly question the validity of India’s stand on both borders. If Bhasin is wrong, he should be challenged. If he’s right, we need to come to terms with the truth.

Marital rape not an ‘offence’ if wife is 18 or above: Allahabad HC

Prayagraj (UP):The Allahabad High Court has observed that marital rape cannot be considered an offence under the Indian Penal Code (IPC) if the wife is above the age of 18....

In first, initiative at Dubai climate talks to reinforce importance of nature in global stocktake

Dubai: For the first time, the UAE UNFCCC COP28 Presidency and the China Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) Presidency have set out a new initiative to galvanize integrated action to...

Latest 5000-point milestone for Sensex from 64k took place in 107 sessions or 5.3 months

New Delhi: Post crossing 67000 points in July '23, it took nearly 93 sessions or 4.6 months for Sensex to cross the 68000 points mark and the next 1000 point...

Rishi Sunak in danger of losing his Premiership

London: Rishi Sunak, 42, the Indian-origin British Prime Minister, is fighting with his back to the wall to save his premiership as well as his political career. Sunak, who has...

Stop fighting, let’s focus on climate justice, children plead to COP28 dignitaries

Dubai: Children are the most impacted by the climate emergency and they represent one third of the world's population (around 2.2 billion people), with half of them (more than one...

Cong raises air pollution, hate speech issues in RS, says those who give such speeches should be barred from contesting polls

New Delhi: The Congress on Thursday raised the issues of air pollution in Delhi and hate speech and demanded that those who give such speeches should be barred from contesting...

90 out of 230 newly-elected MLAs in MP have criminal cases: ADR report

Bhopal: As many as 90 out of the 230 newly-elected MLAs in Madhya Pradesh have criminal cases against them, according to a report released by Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR)....

UN Human Rights Chief warns of ‘atrocity crimes’ in Gaza

United Nations, Dec 6 (IANS) The UN's Human Rights Chief Volker Turk said on Wednesday that Palestinians are living in "utter, deepening, horror, " the media reported. Turk was speaking...

Republican primary not a referendum on Trump but on Biden: US media

Washington: The Republican presidential race ahead of the primaries to the Iowa caucus and New Hampshire meet in another 50 days should have been a referendum on former President Donald...

Delhi: 12 cases under stringent UAPA, crimes against foreign nationals surge

New Delhi: Despite being decried as a tool to stifle dissent, the number of cases filed under the "draconian", Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, commonly known as the anti-terror law, has...

As Kamal Nath fails, murmurs of new chief & LoP in MP Congress

Bhopal: With the Congress suffering a massive defeat, speculation is rife that the party may witness major changes in Madhya Pradesh and a race among the top leaders has begun...

Strategic mistakes, voter fatigue led to BRS defeat

Hyderabad: The failure of Bharat Rashtra Samithi (BRS) leadership to see the undercurrent of anti-incumbency and renomination of almost all the sitting MLAs appear to have cost the party dearly...

Read Previous

China’s military modernisation & its implications for India

Read Next

World War a distant possibility in post-colonial era

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com