India’s Budget 2020: Needs a few course corrections

By Frank Islam

Feb 12, 2020
Washington: In her marathon 2 hours and 46 minutes speech introducing India’s 2020 budget, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman painted an optimistic picture of the Indian economy.

She stated at the outset that her budget’s goal is to boost “incomes and enhance… purchasing power” of the people of India. “Only through higher growth can we achieve that and have our youth gainfully and meaningfully employed,” Sitharaman added.

The Finance Minister’s assessment that higher growth and employment are prerequisites for higher individual incomes and greater purchasing power is spot on. Her optimism is also understandable. Being the stewardess of a $3 trillion economy, one expects her to have confidence in the policies she’s proposing.

However, the budget Sitharaman presented on February 1 was the most comprehensive blueprint submitted by the government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi to date to revive the economy. Examining it contextually, it falls short in a number of areas.

For some time, India has been one of the brightest spots of the global economy. Currently, however, India is in the middle of a major slowdown. The growth rate in the last fiscal quarter was the lowest in 11 years. Last month, the International Monetary Fund downgraded its global growth forecast, putting the blame squarely on India, saying that its woes are dragging the world economy down.

At the moment, India is experiencing its worst employment crisis in 45 years. Several sectors, including financial, real estate and automobile manufacturing, are among the worst-affected. Growth in private consumption in the sixth largest global consumer market has also been a concern for a while.

Given all of this, there were expectations that the budget would advance new major policy initiatives and significant reform measures to kick-start the economy and change the current narrative. This was especially the case because due to the huge mandate Prime Minister Modi received last May the government had plenty of political capital if it wanted to spend some.

However, Sitharaman’s 13,000-word budget speech contained no real bold or big-ticket items. Instead, what was put forward was a classic case of nibbling around the edges.

Not surprisingly, one of the first groups to express disappointment with the budget was India’s investor community, whose negative reaction was reflected in the Sensex losing more than 1,000 points on the budget day. (The losses were erased in subsequent days.)

Three major drivers of economic growth are foreign direct investment (FDI), public and private consumption, and exports.

There wasn’t any serious effort on the part of Sitharaman’s budget to boost any one of these.
The finance minister indicated that she is betting on growing inflows of net FDI, an all-time high accumulation of foreign exchange reserves (which stood at $457.5 billion in December), and improvementin World Bank’s Ease of Doing Business, which now stands at 63.

The budget did offer some sops to foreign portfolio investors, such as tax exemptions to sovereign wealth funds that invest in infrastructure and other critical areas. But it is not nearly enough.

While India remains one of the largest recipients of FDI, foreign investments in sectors such as infrastructure are very modest. A primary reason that foreign investors are reluctant to pump in top dollars in infrastructure development is India’s cumbersome land acquisition laws. As long as there is no change in the status quo in that area, FDI in the sector will continue to lag.

Export is another area where the right policies could make India one of the international leaders. Right now, India stands behind even small nations such as Hong Kong and Singapore in this area. For that to change, India’s manufacturing capabilities will have to be upgraded substantially.

The budget did not outline clear plans to revive troubled sectors such as real estate, financial and automobile manufacturing, which have been adversely affecting the economy. For India to turn the corner these sectors have to perform better and do so fast. Their enhanced performance would help stimulate public and private sector consumption.

Another factor compounding India’s economic problems is that one of the unintended consequences of a recent corporate tax cut was diminished tax revenue. Sitharaman’s decision to levy tax on the Indian income of Non-Resident Indians (NRI) appears to be an attempt to address this by expanding the tax base.

However, judging from the reactions from overseas, that move does not appear to have gone well with the NRI community — which is traditionally a big backer of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party. As a result, it is likely to discourage NRIs from investing in India.

It should be noted that the Budget did have some positives. One of which was a proposal to invest Rs 1.7 trillion to enhance India’s transport infrastructure. That will pay for upgrading key highways, electrifying 27,000 km of railway tracks and building 100 new airports.

Last year, during her first visit to the United States as Finance Finister, Sitharaman said that Prime Minister Modi”s vision of making India a $5 trillion economy in the next five years was achievable. But, her first full-budget as Finance Minister does not provide a sufficient platform for beginning to achieve that vision.

Over the past year, some of the adjectives used by the international media and pundits in the US and Europe to describe the Indian economy were words such as “sagging”, “stuttering” and “floundering”. This commentary continues into this new year. Within hours of the Budget presentation, the Economist in its analysis opined, “It does too little to shore up the flailing economy and failing banks.”

Based upon the foregoing, it must be concluded that with this Budget, the Finance Minister missed an opportunity to change the narrative about the economy and to initiate actions that will make an immediate and positive difference in it. That’s the bad news.

The good news is that a Budget is what it is: a plan for the next 12 months. Governments can and do make course-corrections routinely during a year.

This budget needs course corrections sooner rather later. The right ones addressing the items outlined in this piece and others will set the Indian economy in the proper direction and benefit the Indian people, the Modi administration and the world economy.

(Frank F. Islam is an entrepreneur, civic and thought leader based in Washington DC. The views expressed here are personal).

IS claims 1st Indian suicide bomber was Keralite Christian converted to Islam; agencies begin probe

Thiruvananthapuram: The Central intelligence agencies have commenced a probe after an article in the IS mouthpiece 'Voice of Koharasan' mentioned that 'the first Indian suicide bomber for them was a Keralite...

IT sleuths seized our phones, cloned data, claim Oxfam, IPSMF

Days after the Income Tax Department carried out “surveys action” at their premises, Oxfam India and the Independent and Public-Spirited Media Foundation (IPSMF) alleged that the I-T personnel confiscated phones...

ISI & Khalistani connections of Goldy Brar, Bishnoi

New Delhi, Sep 12 (IANS) The NIA sources have said that Goldy Brar and Lawrence Bishnoi gangs have contacts with Canada-based Khalistani elements and Pakistan-based ISI agents, and these gangs were...

Home Ministry all set to ban PFI after studying possible legal challenges

New Delhi: Days after the NIA and the ED raided several locations linked to the Popular Front of India (PFI) across the country, the Union Home Ministry is planning to...

Centre bans PFI, all its affiliates for 5 years. Here are key reasons

After two rounds of nationwide raids and arrests of over 240 members, the Centre on Wednesday banned the contentious Popular Front of India (PFI) and all its affiliates, excluding the...

Hundreds of jail police personnel go on mass CL in Gujarat

Ahmedabad: Hundreds of police personnel serving at various jails in Gujarat on Wednesday went on a mass casual leave demanding a pay hike at par with other police personnel and State...

Shia leaders demand death for Hafiz Saeed, seek justice for 26/11 victims

Lucknow: The All India Shia Husaini Fund members have demanded justice for the 26/11 Mumbai attack victims by hanging its mastermind, Hafiz Saeed. Shia religious leaders and intellectuals from different...

IIT-K panel to decide if Faiz poem is anti-Hindu

Kanpur, Jan 1 (IANS) In a seemingly bizarre development, the IIT in Kanpur has set up a panel to decide whether the poem "Hum dekhenge lazim hai ki hum bhi...

No internet in Kashmir hospitals despite govt claim

Jan 2, 2019 Srinagar:  Despite government's claim that Internet has been restored in most hospitals and health centres in Kashmir, the facility is yet to be restored in most hospitals....

Millions in sub-Saharan Africa need life-saving food aid: UN

Dec 2, 2020 Rome, Jan 2 (IANS/AKI) Millions of people will require life-saving food assistance in sub-Saharan Africa in the first half of this year amid surging hunger levels that...

RSS ideologue for removing ‘secular’ from Constitution preamble

  Jan 3, 2020 New Delhi:  "Sovereign, socialist, secular, democratic republic" is how India is referred to in the preamble of the Constitution. However, J. Nandakumar, a key RSS leader...

IIT-K tries to dilute Faiz controversy but probe still on

Jan 3, 2019 Kanpur: IIT-Kanpur is apparently caught in a bind over its decision to order a probe into whether poem "Hum dekhenge", written by Faiz Ahmad Faiz, is anti-Hindu...

Read Previous

Dharmendra to launch new restaurant He-Man on V’Day

Read Next

Kapil, Azharuddin urge BCCI to take action against U-19 players

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com