We have turned our back on Rushdie

I’m perplexed and dismayed by the cold indifference with which most of our politicians have responded to the savage attack on Salman Rushdie. In 1988 we were the only major democracy to ban Satanic Verses. We did so without reading the book. Thirty four years later we’re the only major democracy not to condemn the attack. I truly cannot understand why.

Salman Rushdie was born in India. Though his citizenship may have changed, he continues to identify with this country. In 2000, in an interview for the BBC’s HardTalk India, I asked him: “Is this country still home?” This was his reply: “There’s a sense in which the country in which you were born and grew up as a child is always home. You never have that feeling about any other place. Anyone who reads my books knows the extent to which my imagination calls this country home.”

If anything his answer to my next question was even more telling. I asked: “If I was to ask is Salman Rushdie Indian or English or Pakistani, which identity would you accept?” His response was short, stark but simple: “Oh not Pakistani!” The laugh that followed sounded more like a sneer. He found the very idea of being Pakistani ludicrous.

So why is there no public expression of horror and condemnation from our leading politicians? Why are they unable to voice anger at what happened? Why are they unwilling to even state their concern for his recovery? Indeed, why are they just silent?

No doubt a small handful have spoken but the only party leader to do so is Sitaram Yechury. The rest, it seems, have nothing to say. That list includes not just the Prime Minister and his entire cabinet but also Sonia and Rahul Gandhi, Mamata Banerjee, Naveen Patnaik, M. K. Stalin, Nitish Kumar, Conrad Sangma, Farooq and Omar Abdullah. Is it really the case that not one of this lot felt anything when they learnt of the attack on Rushdie? Or has politics and the fear of offending Muslim voters – or the Iranian government – silenced them?

The full truth is the External Affairs Minister has spoken but when you consider what he said it’s arguable silence might have been preferable. In response to a question at a press conference in Bangalore he said: “I also read about it. This is something that the whole world has noticed and the whole world has reacted to such an attack.” The whole world, yes, but not our External Affairs Minister. His was not a reaction to the attack – and certainly not a condemnation of it – but merely an acknowledgement that he was aware of it.

Rushdie is possibly the greatest, certainly the most widely read and by far the best known, author of Indian origin. Yet we’ve turned our back on him. Meanwhile, the rest of the world has embraced him and made him their own. “His fight is our fight”, said France’s President Macron. “Now more than ever, we stand by his side.”

So, let me ask bluntly, who’s side are we on? There are occasions when you need to make it clear and obvious. In this instance the disturbing questions also affect our stature as the world’s largest democracy. When someone we should proudly call our own is attacked why is it that we have nothing to say? And what does this suggest of our attitude to the Indian diaspora? Is Rushdie not one of its shining stars? Or is the faith he was born into – which he doesn’t follow – the problem?

Let me give Rushdie the last word. In the BBC interview I asked if he felt rejected by India. For years it denied him a visa. “Yes I did”, he replied. “I felt very hurt. I did feel the exile from India to be one of the most painful things of those years. I loved to come. I used to come every year.” Now, perhaps, our silence has added to his hurt.


MCD polls: Congress poor show sets stage for AAP; BJP still resilient force in Delhi politics

New Delhi: The AAP managed a prestige win by dislodging the 15-year-old BJP’s rule in the municipal corporation of Delhi even as the saffron party did not fare as badly...

Christian Michel alleges abuse in Tihar Jail to UK PM

London: Christian Michel, an alleged middleman in the AgustaWestland chopper scam case, has claimed in a signed five-page hand-written letter from Tihar Jail to UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak that...

‘If he was an Indian, he would have been granted bail’, SC on Michel’s bail pleas

New Delhi, Dec 6 (IANS) The Supreme Court on Tuesday questioned the Centre that for how long will it keep Christian Michel, who is a foreign national, behind the bars, and...

Delhi HC defers petitions seeking recognition of same-sex marriages

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court on Tuesday deferred petitions seeking recognition of same-sex marriages under the Hindu Marriage Act and the Special Marriage Act. The batch of petitions will be...

BJP may use Hindutva card ahead of 2023 polls in MP

Bhopal: 'Hindutva' has undoubtedly been a key tool of polarisation in the politics of the BJP, but it had very little impact in Madhya Pradesh, be it pre-demolition or post-demolition Babri...

Montreal COP15: Crucial for 196 nations to halt, reverse nature loss by 2030

New Delhi: As delegates of 196 nations gather over the next two weeks for the UN biodiversity summit, referred to as COP15, beginning in Montreal, Canada, to agree, amongst other...

Closed down Coke factory property to be given to Kerala govt, protesters up in arms

  Thiruvananthapuram: The Plachimada Struggle Solidarity Committee, which through its long drawn struggle saw to the closure of the Coca-Cola factory in Palakkad district in 2004, is getting ready for...

Scientist who worked at Wuhan lab claims Covid-19 was man-made by US

The pandemic was caused by the US government's funding of coronaviruses in China, says book by US scientist, The Truth About Wuhan The US government is toblame for the transfer...

Italy home to highest number of unofficial Chinese ‘police stations’: Report

Rome: Italy hosts the highest number of unofficial Chinese "police stations" out of a network of more than 100 around the world, a report by a Spanish civil rights group has...

SL to get help from India’s NDDB to develop dairy industry

Colombo: Sri Lankan President Ranil Wickremesinghe has appointed a committee to work with Indias National Dairy Development Board (NDDB) to develop the island nation's dairy industry. The committee consisting of representatives...

Cong in Kerala smells a rat over rendezvous between Goa Guv, Jose K.Mani

Thiruvananthapuram : The Kerala unit of Congress on Monday flayed a recent meeting between Goa Governor P.S.Sreedharan Pillai and Jose K.Mani from Kerala Congress-- ruling Left Front's ally -- calling...

Allahabad HC wants to know why not ban caste rallies?

Prayagraj:  The Lucknow bench of Allahabad High Court has issued fresh notices to the four major political parties of Uttar Pradesh seeking their response on why there should not be...

Read Previous

Brazil to play Ghana, Tunisia in pre-World Cup friendlies

Read Next

Ex-J&K CM Mehbooba Mufti placed under house arrest

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com