Conspiracy claims against PM can’t be made irresponsibly; it needs cogent, substantial reasons: Delhi HC on Pinaki Misra’s defamation suit

Delhi High Court. (File Photo: IANS)

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court on Wednesday observed that allegations of conspiracy against the Prime Minister cannot be made irresponsibly and need to be based on “cogent and substantial reasons.”

The High Court said this while hearing a defamation suit by BJD MP Pinaki Misra against Advocate Jai Anant Dehadrai over claims of corruption.

The court said that the conspiracy to target the PM is an offence under IPC. “It is treason,” Justice Jasmeet Singh said.

Misra, who is also a senior advocate, has sought relief of permanent injunction and damages against the defendants — Dehadrai, ANI, PTI and X — urging the court to restrain them from making, publishing, circulating ex facie false and defamatory allegations against him.

BJD’s Misra is a Lok Sabha MP representing the Puri constituency in Odisha.

He has alleged that Dehadrai called him “Canning Lane”, “Odia Babu” and “Dalal of Puri”.

Justice Jasmeet Singh on Wednesday issued summons on Misra’s suit. However, the court will continue to hear at 2:30 pm.

Advocate Samudra Sarangi appeared for Misra and Dehadrai was represented through Advocate Raghav Awasthi.

On the allegation of Misra being the architect of the conspiracy to target the Prime Minister, his counsel Sarangi said that my party (BJD) is ideologically aligned with the BJP and the Prime Minister.

The judge asked Dehadrai’s counsel how had Misra targeted the Prime Minister.

The court said, “These are very serious allegations against the PM. You can’t be trigger-happy. You are alleging serious allegations of conspiracy against the PM by a sitting MP. You explain it or I will injunct you.”

Awasthi responded saying that his client has personally witnessed it.

“The second aspect is the sworn affidavit by Mr Darshan Hiranandani,” Awasthi said.

Making submissions by himself, Dehadrai said, “I have personally witnessed conversations between Hiranandani, Ms Moitra and Pinaki Misra. Misra would write her speeches and explain what kind of allegations to make.”

Justice Singh said, “What you are saying has very serious consequences. It affects the highest office of the country.”

He added, “When you say conspiracy against the PM, it is a very serious issue. You can’t be trigger-happy. You may say plaintiff is a politician and he can’t be thin skinned, I agree with that. But what you are alleging is very serious.”

Misra has alleged that on October 14, 2023, a CBI complaint was filed by Dehadrai against Mahua Moitra wherein he made a slew of allegations against her on account of the personal differences between them.

Later, Misra alleged, Dehadrai created pseudonymous account named “Chandraswami Pinaki Moitra” (this account was previously named – “Ahmed Ansari”) and published the first tweet on this account.

He began publishing tweets on X which contains references to “Canning Lane” and “Oriya Babu/Odia Babu.”

Misra has claimed that Dehadrai published a tweet with a picture of Moitra speaking in Parliament, while Misra was seated adjacent to her.

He further alleges that Dehadrai published a tweet with various pictures of Moitra and him (Misra) during Lok Sabha proceedings, and published tweets indicating the actual target of his allegations.

Misra has accused Dehadrai of specifically naming him in his interviews to ANI and PTI, saying that Dehadrai made ex facie false and per se defamatory allegations, and continued to publish tweets with fraudulent, frivolous and baseless allegations against him without having any shred of evidence.

Misra’s suit says, “In the said CBI complaint, Defendant No. 1 (Dehadrai) made various allegations of bribery and corruption against Ms Mahua Moitra. However, in addition to making allegations against Ms Mahua Moitra, for reasons best known to Defendant No. 1, he sought to make the following false allegations as well: ‘This tranche of Rs 2 crore in cash was made via hawala channels to a very close associate of Smt. Mahua Moitra, also a Member of Parliament from Orissa, with whom the funds were ultimately kept for safekeeping. There were also purchases made on behalf of Smt. Moitra of high value items, such as high-end furniture, by the same MP from Orissa, who would then deduct the value from the cash kept with him for safekeeping. This furniture was purchased from a company called M/s OBEETEE and is presently kept at 9B Telegraph Lane – but invoiced to the MP from Orissa….. The informant witnessed multiple meetings between herself, the MP from Orissa and official from CPWD – discussing a myriad ways in which it could be renovated to suit her needs.’”

Misra further said, “However, by January 2024, it was beginning to become clear that Defendant No. 1’s intentions were considerably sinister.”

According to Misra, Dehadrai’s tweet read, “Such an interesting coincidence that in every attack targeting the Prime Minister @narendramodi – outside and particularly inside the Parliament, the looming presence of one man from Odisha is unmistakable.”


Panel to review new criminal laws triggers war of words in Bengal

Kolkata: A political slugfest erupted in West Bengal on Thursday over the state government notification on Wednesday on the formation of a seven-member committee to review the three new criminal...

Shivaji’s ‘wagh-nakh’ brought back from London, historian questions its ‘authenticity’

New Delhi: The 'wagh-nakh' (tiger claws) used by the Maratha warrior Shivaji has been brought back from London and will be put on display in Maharashtra's Satara district from Friday....

UN condemns killing of 468 civilians by militias in South Sudan

Juba: The United Nations Mission in South Sudan (UNMISS) expressed concern about widespread attacks against civilians, driven primarily by sub-national armed violence involving community-based militia groups in the country. The...

Monsoons may trigger brain infections in Indians living in coastal areas, rice belts

Faridabad: Children and the elderly living in coastal and rice belt regions of India are highly vulnerable for viral encephalitis and other brain infections during monsoon, said a neurologist at...

Four in five voters concerned over US spiraling out of control after Trump’s shooting: poll

New York: Four in five Americans are concerned about increasing political violence following an assassination attempt on former US President Donald Trump, and fear that the United States "is spiraling...

Vietnamese hackers fuelling WhatsApp e-challan scam in India: Report

Bengaluru: A highly technical Android malware campaign by Vietnamese hackers is targeting Indian users through fake traffic e-challan messages on WhatsApp, according to a report on Wednesday. Researchers from CloudSEK,...

NASA scientists use AI to analyse rocks on Red Planet

New Delhi: In a first, the Perseverance Mars Rover Mission used Artificial Intelligence (AI) on the Red Planet to make autonomous decisions based on real-time analysis of rock composition, said...

Burglar empties Maharashtra litterateur’s home; repents and returns everything!

Raigad (Maharashtra): In a bizarre instance, a burglar sneaked in and emptied the locked home of the legendary Marathi litterateur, Padmashri Narayan Gangaram Surve, recently in Neral town, a police...

Who is Usha Chilukuri Vance, Indian-origin wife of Trump’s running mate for VP post

New Delhi: Former US President Donald Trump on Monday picked JD Vance, a first-time senator from Ohio, as his running mate and nominee for the Vice-President post. JD Vance, 40...

Trump reveals a softer, mellower side after assassination bid

Washington: Former US President Donald Trump has said that he threw away an “extremely tough” speech prepared for accepting the party nomination at the Republican convention starting Monday and will...

Foreign Secretary Misri’s China stint to count in ongoing geopolitical turmoil

New Delhi: Vikram Misri, who took over as India's Foreign Secretary on Monday, has served in various capacities at the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) headquarters in New Delhi, various...

Three lessons for Indian politics from British polls

NEW DELHI :For nearly a decade we’ve grown accustomed to viewing Britain in terms of its flailing economy, faltering politicians, crumbling infrastructure and steadily diminishing stature. We weren’t wrong. But...

Read Previous

Where are the two crore jobs that were promised, asks Congress chief Kharge as Kerala prepares to vote

Read Next

Congress distances itself from Sam Pitroda’s inheritance tax comment, says his views not always aligned with party

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By :