Government leaves it to SC’s wisdom to decriminalize gay sex

July 11, 2018
New Delhi: The centre on Wednesday said it was leaving it to the wisdom of the Supreme Court to decide if a law that criminalizes consensual gay sex was constitutionally valid.

On the second day of the Supreme Court hearing on the plea challenging the constitutional validity of Indian Penal Code’s Section 377 that criminalises homosexuality, the Centre did not spell out its stand one way or the other

However, it urged the five-judge constitution bench of Chief Justice Dipak Misra, Justices Rohinton Fali Nariman, A.M. Khanwilkar, D.Y. Chandrachud and Indu Malhotra that they should confine to deciding the challenge to the law without any scope that may give rise to LGBT community claiming civil rights including right to property, inheritance marriage, adoption and other rights.

“What ever may not be in question may not be decided,” Additional Solicitor General Tushar Mehta told the court expressing the apprehension of the Centre.

He told the court that if it intended to touch on other issues like same sex marriage, then the Centre will file another detailed affidavit.

Airing the government’s concerns, Mehta referred to Justice Chandrachud’s observation made during the course of the hearing on Tuesday that in Hadiya judgement, that “we have already decided that the right to choose partner is a fundamental right”.

Clarifying his observation, Justice Chandrachud said they were not going to decide “kinky issues”.

“We are (debating) on whether the relationship between two adults is itself a manifestation of Article 21 of the Constitution,” he said.

“We don’t want a situation when two gays enjoying a walk on Marine Drive should be disturbed by police and charged under Section 377 IPC,” he said.

Chief Justice Misra said: “We will decide whether consensual sex between two consenting adults is a crime or not.”

Dispelling the apprehensions of the Centre, he said: “We can’t judge an issue in vacuum” thereby telling Mehta that the issue of other rights of LGBT community was not before the bench.(IANS)

SDPI slams Centre for suspension of scholarships to students

Bangalore: Karnataka unit of Social Democratic Party of India (SDPI) has slammed BJP-led government at Centre for suspending scholarships meant for students from Class 1 to 8. Abdul Majid Mysore, State...

NIA gets 4 more days custodial remand of Lawrence Bishnoi

New Delhi: A Special Delhi court on Saturday extended custodial remand of Gangster Lawrence Bishnoi by four days in connection with the gangster-terrorist nexus matter. Bishnoi was produced before the court...

Sexual relationship on pretext of marriage: SC grants anticipatory bail to accused

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has granted anticipatory bail to an accused facing rape charge, where the victim alleged that the accused established sexual relationship with her on the pretext of...

Hyderabad University professor suspended for alleged sexual assault of foreign student

Hyderabad: The University of Hyderabad on Saturday suspended Professor Ravi Ranjan, hours after he was arrested by the police on allegations of trying to sexually assault a foreign student. The Central...

CCTV in classrooms ensure students’ safety, right to privacy not violated: Delhi govt to HC

New Delhi: The Delhi government recently told the High Court that one major reason behind its 2017 decision is to save and secure students from sexual abuse and bullying in view...

Bommai announces Rs 15 lakh compensation for families of leopard attack victims

Bengaluru: Karnataka Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai on Saturday announced Rs 15 lakh compensation to families of those killed in the leopard attacks. "For families of persons who were killed in leopard...

Delhi man kills live-in partner, tries to chop up body

The accused allegedly stabbed Rekha in the face and neck, and as she resisted, a finger of her right hand was mutilated The 45-year-old man, identified as Manpreet, who was...

Chhattisgarh Assembly passes 2 amendment bills on reservation, takes quota to 76%

As per the Bills, 32% of the seats will be reserved for ST, 13% for ST and 4% for EWS Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel said that it was a historic...

A foreign student at Hyderabad University alleges rape attempt by professor

  Hyderabad:  A foreign student at the University of Hyderabad has alleged that a professor of trying to sexually assault her. The victim, who is from Thailand, lodged a complaint...

K’taka: Probe against shuttler Lakshya Sen for fudging age

Bengaluru:  Karnataka police have initiated a probe against international badminton player Lakshya Sen for allegedly providing false details about his age, police said on Saturday. The probe has been initiated...

Paresh Rawal faces police case for ‘distastesful comment against Bengalis

Mr. Salim has written to police asking them to treat his complaint as an FIR and prosecute the BJP leader Trinamool Congress in Bengal has hit out at actor Paresh...

Gujarat Polls: 60% females and 65% males voted in first phase, total turnout 63.31%

Gandhinagar: In the first phase, 63.31 per cent of the voters cast their votes in 89 assembly seats in Saurashtra and Kutch and South Gujarat. Out of the total 2,39,76,670...

Read Previous

Death toll in Japan flood hits 179

Read Next

ED seeks court order declaring Nirav Modi, Choksi fugitives

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com