Government leaves it to SC’s wisdom to decriminalize gay sex

July 11, 2018
New Delhi: The centre on Wednesday said it was leaving it to the wisdom of the Supreme Court to decide if a law that criminalizes consensual gay sex was constitutionally valid.

On the second day of the Supreme Court hearing on the plea challenging the constitutional validity of Indian Penal Code’s Section 377 that criminalises homosexuality, the Centre did not spell out its stand one way or the other

However, it urged the five-judge constitution bench of Chief Justice Dipak Misra, Justices Rohinton Fali Nariman, A.M. Khanwilkar, D.Y. Chandrachud and Indu Malhotra that they should confine to deciding the challenge to the law without any scope that may give rise to LGBT community claiming civil rights including right to property, inheritance marriage, adoption and other rights.

“What ever may not be in question may not be decided,” Additional Solicitor General Tushar Mehta told the court expressing the apprehension of the Centre.

He told the court that if it intended to touch on other issues like same sex marriage, then the Centre will file another detailed affidavit.

Airing the government’s concerns, Mehta referred to Justice Chandrachud’s observation made during the course of the hearing on Tuesday that in Hadiya judgement, that “we have already decided that the right to choose partner is a fundamental right”.

Clarifying his observation, Justice Chandrachud said they were not going to decide “kinky issues”.

“We are (debating) on whether the relationship between two adults is itself a manifestation of Article 21 of the Constitution,” he said.

“We don’t want a situation when two gays enjoying a walk on Marine Drive should be disturbed by police and charged under Section 377 IPC,” he said.

Chief Justice Misra said: “We will decide whether consensual sex between two consenting adults is a crime or not.”

Dispelling the apprehensions of the Centre, he said: “We can’t judge an issue in vacuum” thereby telling Mehta that the issue of other rights of LGBT community was not before the bench.(IANS)

Major quake shakes north India, triggers panic

New Delhi: Strong tremors, lasting for several seconds, shook most of north India on Tuesday evening, creating panic among the people. According to the US Geological Services, the 6.5 magnitude...

JD-U’s new Executive Committee announced, K.C. Tyagi not in list

Patna: After a long time, Janata Dal United (JD-U) on Tuesday announced a new national Executive Committee and senior leader Mangni Lal Mandal has been given the post of national...

‘Bunch of illiterate people from top to bottom’: Kejriwal on Delhi Budget row

New Delhi: Addressing the ongoing Delhi assembly session over the budget row, Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal on Tuesday said that "there is a bunch of illiterate people from top to...

Biden okays bill to declassify intelligence info on Covid origins

Washington: US President Joe Biden has signed a bill to declassify intelligence information on the origins of the Covid pandemic, which has so far claimed more than seven million lives...

Mumbai court rejects Javed Akhtar’s plea over remarks comparing RSS with Taliban

A sessions court in Mumbai rejected a plea filed by lyricist Javed Akhtar challenging a Magistrate order summoning him in a criminal defamation complaint for his alleged remarks comparing the...

Sambit Patra calls Rahul Gandhi present-day Mir Jafar of Indian politics

New Delhi: BJP national spokesperson Sambit Patra on Tuesday called Congress leader Rahul Gandhi present-day Mir Jafar of Indian politics and sought an apology over the latter's speech in the...

Kejriwal writes to PM Modi over ‘stopping’ Delhi Budget

New Delhi: Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal on Tuesday wrote to Prime Minister Narendra Modi over "stopping" of the national capital's Budget. "For the first time in the history of...

Moscow opens criminal case against ICC over Putin warrant

Moscow: The International Criminal Court (ICC) prosecutor and judges, who issued an arrest warrant against Russian President Vladimir Putin, have become the targets of a criminal case, Russias Investigative Committee announced...

Delhi govt tables Eco Survey, per capita income grew by 14.18% in 2022-23

New Delhi: The national capital's per capita income grew by 14.18 per cent at the current prices in 2022-23 to Rs 4,44,768 compared to Rs 3,89,529 during 2021-22, the Delhi...

LS adjourned for the day amid protests by treasury benches over Rahul’s remarks

New Delhi: The Lok Sabha was on Monday adjourned for the day till Tuesday after noisy protests by treasury benches over Rahul Gandhi's remarks on democracy. As soon as the...

India’s envoy to Canada cancels event due to protests linked to Amritpal Singh; Sikh student assaulted  

India’s High Commissioner to Ottawa Sanjay Kumar Verma forced to cancel an event due to concerns over his safety after hundreds of protestors wielding swords blocked the entrance to the...

WB teachers’ scam: After 40 hours of search operation, ED arrests promoter Ayan Shil

Kolkata: After around 40 hours of marathon raid and search operations, the Enforcement Directorate (ED) has finally arrested private real-estate promoter Ayan Shil in connection with the multi-crore scam in...

Read Previous

Death toll in Japan flood hits 179

Read Next

ED seeks court order declaring Nirav Modi, Choksi fugitives

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com