‘Collegium discussions can’t be put out in public domain through RTI’, says SC

Supreme Court.

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Friday dismissed a plea seeking to disclose details under the Right to Information (RTI) of a collegium meeting in which decisions were taken regarding the elevation of judges to the apex court.

A bench headed by Justice M.R. Shah said, “Only a resolution drawn and signed by all the collegium members can be said to be the final decision…”

The bench added that “it is to be noted that final decision is taken by the collegium only after due consultation and during the consultation some decision takes place, but no final decision is taken and no resolution is drawn, it cannot be said that a final decision is taken by the collegium”.

“Collegium is a multi-member body whose decision embodies into the resolution that may be formally drawn up and signed…,” said the bench, adding that only the final decision was required to be uploaded on the Supreme Court’s website.

It further added that whatever was discussed in the collegium was not required to be put out in the public domain, that too under the RTI Act.

The top court judgment came on a petition by activist Anjali Bhardwaj against the Delhi High Court order, which dismissed her plea seeking apex court collegium’s agenda in connection with a meeting held on December 12, 2018 when certain decisions were purportedly taken on the elevation of some judges to the apex court.

On December 2, the Supreme Court, taking a dig at retired judges, said, “It has become a fashion for them to comment about earlier decisions taken by the collegium, and the existing collegium system should not be derailed on the basis of statements of some busybody”. The apex court emphasized that the collegium was the most transparent institution.

The bench said that it did not want to comment on what a few former apex court judges, who were once members of the Supreme Court Collegium, were now saying about the mechanism.

Advocate Prashant Bhushan, representing the petitioner RTI activist Anjali Bhardwaj, said Justice Madan Lokur, former apex court judge, who was part of the Supreme Court Collegium in 2018, had said that one of the decisions, should have been uploaded on the Supreme Court website.

The bench said, “Nowadays, it has become a fashion to comment upon earlier decisions (of the collegium) made when they (former judges) were part of the collegium”. It further added, “We don’t want to say anything on their comments”.

The collegium, which was headed by then CJI Ranjan Gogoi and comprising four senior-most judges Justices Lokur, A.K. Sikri, S.A. Bobde, and N.V. Ramana took certain decisions regarding the appointment of judges. However, details were not uploaded on the website. In January 2019, the collegium revisited the decisions “in the light of additional materials”.IANS

Tripura tribal party to adopt resolution against CAA within 150 days after ‘coming to power’

Agartala : Tipra Motha Party (TMP), which has been demanding to upgrade the Tripura Tribal Areas Autonomous District Council (TTAADC) as a full-fledged state, would pass a resolution against the...

Centre notifies appointment of 5 new judges to Supreme Court

New Delhi: Amid the long-drawn tussle between the Centre and the judiciary over appointment of judges, the Centre on Saturday cleared the names of five judges for appointment to the Supreme...

‘Amended UAPA is menace to democracy’: Shashi Tharoor on journalist’s release

‘Siddique Kappan release after 28 months in jail reminds us that UAPA allows the government to detain people indefinitely without charge’ The Kerala journalist asked for reading material in jail...

‘Criminal conspiracy’: Lawyer moves SC seeking a probe into Hindenburg report

' New Delhi: A PIL has been moved in the Supreme Court seeking a direction to the Centre and the SEBI to inquire into alleged "criminal conspiracy" behind the Hindenburg...

J’khand HC grants relief to Rahul Gandhi in case pertaining to remarks against Amit Shah

Ranchi: The Jharkhand High Court has granted relief to former Congress president Rahul Gandhi in a case related to his remarks against former BJP president Amit Shah. The court has...

Don’t make us take a hard stand’, SC warns Centre on delaying judges’ transfer

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Friday warned the Centre on the delay in clearing the transfer of high court judges recommended by the apex court collegium, saying it may...

SC agrees to hear plea seeking prohibition of hate speech

The Supreme Court has expressed concern over hate speech and agreed to hear a plea seeking to prohibit Hindu Janakrosh Morcha event scheduled be held on February 5 in Mumbai....

Hindu Sena files PIL in SC seeking ban on BBC’s operation in India

A far right group has filed a PIL in the Supreme Court seeking imposition of complete ban on the BBC from operating in the country as well as a probe...

If accused is dead, fine can be collected from successors: K’taka HC

Bengaluru: The Karnataka High Court in an important judgment stated that the fine can be collected from the property or from the successors who inherit from the accused even after...

SC seeks info on inadequate SC, ST representation in promotions

The Supreme Court has sought information from all states on the yardstick being adopted to identify the inadequate representation of Scheduled Castes (SC) and Scheduled Tribes (ST) in reservation for...

SC Collegium recommends two more names for appointment as judges

The two names are: Allahabad High Court Chief Justice Rajesh Bindal and Gujarat High Court Chief Justice Aravind Kumar. The resolution said that the judicial appointment body took into consideration...

Gujarat HC sets up panel to probe denial of medical care to pregnant women

Ahmedabad,: A division bench of the Gujarat High Court has set up a committee to be headed by retired justice to look into two incidents where pregnant women were allegedly...

Read Previous

Many marine species may go extinct before discovered: Scientists at COP15

Read Next

NCPCR seeks probe report on madrasas admitting non-Muslim kids

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com