‘Hold your mouth’, Attorney General to SC during EC appointment hearing

New Delhi: Attorney General (AG) R. Venkataramani, representing the Centre, on Thursday told a five-judge Supreme Court bench to “hold its mouth”, as he faced a volley of questions in connection with the process adopted on the appointment of Arun Goel as an Election Commissioner (EC).

As the hearing commenced, the bench headed by Justice K.M. Joseph and comprising Justices Ajay Rastogi, Aniruddha Bose, Hrishikesh Roy and C.T. Ravikumar, shot a volley of questions at the AG in connection with Goel’s appointment process, and specifically repeated a question on how did the Law Minister filter the names from the database of Department of Personnel & Training (DoPT), which were to be considered for the appointment.

It also carefully examined the original file of Goel’s appointment as an EC, which was placed before the court and asked the AG that it is keen to understand how the Law Minister picks up the names from the database.

However, at a juncture when the judges were asking questions, the AG asked the court to “hold its mouth” and requested it to look into the matter in the larger perspective.

“Please hold your mouth for a while. I request to look into the issue in entirety,” the AG told the bench.

“We don’t have anything against an individual. This man, infact, is excellent in terms of academics. But we are concerned with the structure of the appointment.”

The bench further added that there were four names, which were recommended and it wants to understand that out of the vast reservoir of names, how were these 4 names shortlisted.

Clarifying that it is questioning the merit of the EC but the process, the bench queried the AG: “Someone who was about to be superannuated in December. He is the youngest among the four names who were recommended. Is that a criteria?”

The AG told the bench that there is a certain basis for shortlisting, such as seniority, retirement, tenure, and emphasized the process of appointing the EC and Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) has worked well so far and there is no arbitrariness in the process.

The AG said all the ECs were appointed through a quick process.

The bench further questioned the AG on what is the foundation of this process (shortlisting for names from the data of DoPT).

Justice Joseph categorically asked the AG: “How did the Law Minister zero in on these four names?”

To this, the AG said that he had already explained the process but the bench was not convinced.

The top court made these observations during the hearing on a batch of pleas seeking a collegium-like system for the appointment of the ECs and chief election commissioner (CEC).

The Supreme Court on Wednesday told the Centre that it wants to see the files relating to Goel’s appointment and emphasized that it wants to see by what mechanism, “he was picked up”, and “there is no danger to produce it (files)”.


Dhankar raises issue of SC scrapping NJAC Act in maiden speech as RS Chairman

New Delhi: Rajya Sabha Chairman Jagdeep Dhankar on Wednesday raised the issue of the Supreme Court striking down the NJAC act during his maiden speech in the House. "A glaring instance...

Muslim personal law board to move SC against acquittal of 32 accused in Babri Masjid demolition case

The All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB) on Wednesday said it will move the Supreme Court against a CBI special court acquittal of all the 32 accused in the...

‘If he was an Indian, he would have been granted bail’, SC on Michel’s bail pleas

New Delhi, Dec 6 (IANS) The Supreme Court on Tuesday questioned the Centre that for how long will it keep Christian Michel, who is a foreign national, behind the bars, and...

Delhi HC defers petitions seeking recognition of same-sex marriages

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court on Tuesday deferred petitions seeking recognition of same-sex marriages under the Hindu Marriage Act and the Special Marriage Act. The batch of petitions will be...

‘India is a secular country’, SC junks plea to declare Thakur Anukulchandra as ‘Pramatma’

India is a secular country and everybody has a right to their religion, the Supreme Court said on Monday while dismissing a PIL seeking to declare late religious figure Sri...

SC says ‘forced’ religious conversion serious issue, asks Centre to file affidavit

The plea by BJP leader and advocate Ashwini Upadhyay seeks stringent steps to tackle forceful religious conversions Critics are of the view that the stringent anti-conversion law is against the...

‘Purpose of charity must not be conversion’, SC on plea against forced conversion

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Monday reiterated that the issue of forced religious conversion is a "very serious issue" and emphasized that charity is welcome, but the purpose of charity...

Allahabad HC wants to know why not ban caste rallies?

Prayagraj:  The Lucknow bench of Allahabad High Court has issued fresh notices to the four major political parties of Uttar Pradesh seeking their response on why there should not be...

Hyderabad varsity prof jailed for sexually harassing foreign student

Hyderabad:  A professor of University of Hyderabad has been sent to jail on allegation of trying to sexually assault a foreign student. Ravi Ranjan, a professor in the Department of...

‘Nepotism does happen’: SCBA prez pinpoints flaws in judges’ appointment

New Delhi: Senior advocate and Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) President Vikas Singh, in an interview with IANS on the appointment of judges, said he is not saying nepotism is institutionally...

If Centre gets complete control, judiciary won’t be free: Ex-SC judge Madan Lokur

New Delhi,:  Former Supreme Court judge Justice Madan B. Lokur, in an interview with IANS, said "the manner in which the executive has been dealing with the recommendations of the...

‘Nepotism does happen’: SCBA prez pinpoints flaws in judges’ appointment

New Delhi:  Senior advocate and Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) President Vikas Singh, in an interview with IANS on the appointment of judges, said he is not saying nepotism is...

Read Previous

Mangaluru blast: Islamic outfit claims responsibility, warns of another attack

Read Next

Gurugram: National-level athlete player among 5 thrashed by bar bouncers, manager

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com