J&K Assembly creature of its Constitution and not Constitution of India’

By Sumit Saxena
Jan 21, 2020

New Delhi: The Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Assembly is a creature of the Constitution of the erstwhile state, and not the Constitution of India, submitted senior journalist Prem Shankar Jha’s counsel, challenging the scrapping of Article 370, before the Supreme Court on Tuesday.

Senior advocate Dinesh Dwivedi, representing Jha, told a five-judge Constitution Bench headed by Justice N.V. Ramana, that: “Legislative Assembly is one which is a creature of the Constitution of J&K and not the Constitution of India where Governor cannot be a substitute.”

He insisted that Constituent Assembly was independent of the Constitution.

“The Legislative Assembly cannot be a substitute or the successor of even the Constituent Assembly of Jammu and Kashmir,” Dwivedi.

To bolster his argument, he said that the Legislative Assembly is the creature of the Constituent Assembly of Jammu and Kashmir, which was a plenary sovereign authority unlike the Legislative Assembly.

He also added that J&K Constituent Assembly was dissolved in 1957 after the formulation of the J&K Constitution, and as a consequence, Article 370 was apparently frozen.

Dwivedi also argued that the presidential orders issued on August 5-6 are per se illegal in as much as the Constitution of Jammu and Kashmir being outside the Constitution of India. “And Article 370, it can only be repealed, ceased or suspended in the manner prescribed by the supervising law of J&K only and not otherwise. What cannot be done directly, cannot be done indirectly also,” he argued.

He insisted that these presidential orders, as they intend to apply all provisions of the Constitution of India are null and void, since they have the effect of repealing the Constitution of J&K and replacing it with “Constitution of India by an executive order”.

He emphasised that Constitutions are real codes of governance for an undefined period, and they can only be modified or amended in exercise of the self-confined amendatory powers.

Dwivedi said that Article 370 was apparently a tunnel connecting the two Constitutions, and insisted that its sole object was to ensure that people of the region have a say in their governance through their own Constitution. The senior advocate argued that Parliament could exercise few powers on the erstwhile state – alter its boundary and change the name, but cannot convert it into a Union Territory.

He also urged the court to refer the matter to a larger bench against the backdrop of two conflicting decisions – 1959 and 1970 – by a five-judge bench of the apex court on the subject. While the former recognized the temporary nature of Article 370, the latter recognises its permanence by giving the source of power to the Union, and also allows it to regulate the governing relationship between the Centre and state.

The arguments on the matter will continue on Wednesday.IANS

‘India Got Latent’ row: SC orders release of Ranveer Allahbadia’s passport

New Delhi: In another relief to popular YouTube Ranveer Allahbadia, the Supreme Court on Monday directed the return of his passport. Allahbadia, who made obscene and offensive remarks about parents...

SC refuses to entertain fresh plea against Waqf (Amendment) Act

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Monday refused to entertain a fresh petition challenging the recent amendments to the Waqf Act, 1995. A bench, headed by CJI Sanjiv Khanna, told...

Gold smuggling case: Karnataka HC dismisses actress Ranya Rao’s bail plea

Bengaluru: The Karnataka High Court on Saturday dismissed the bail plea of actress Ranya Rao in connection with the gold smuggling case. The bail application of the second accused, Tarun...

National Herald case: Delhi court declines to take cognisance of ED’s charge sheet against Sonia, Rahul

New Delhi: A court here on Friday declined to issue notice to Congress Parliamentary Party Chairperson Sonia Gandhi and Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi in the...

Medha Patkar arrested in Delhi L-G defamation case

New Delhi: Activist Medha Patkar was arrested here on Friday after the court issued a non-bailable warrant against her in a defamation case filed by Delhi Lt Governor V.K. Saxena....

PIL in SC over ‘contemptuous’ remarks of BJP MP Nishikant Dubey

New Delhi: A public interest litigation has been filed in the Supreme Court against the "contemptuous act" committed by BJP Lok Sabha member Nishikant Dubey in "scandalising" the top court...

K’taka ex-DGP murder: Wife sent to judicial custody, daughter admitted to NIMHANS

Bengaluru: The wife of former Karnataka DGP Om Prakash, Pallavi, was arrested in connection with his murder and was remanded to judicial custody, police said on Tuesday. DCP South-East Sarah...

HC asks Delhi govt, MCD to act against illegal encroachments on Yamuna Pusta Road

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has ordered the Municipal Corporation of Delhi and the city government to act against illegal encroachments prevailing along the Yamuna Pusta Road, which stretches...

Murshidabad violence: Calcutta HC orders formation of review committee

Kolkata: A special division bench of the Calcutta High Court, on Thursday, directed the formation of a committee to review the situation in minority-dominated Murshidabad district of West Bengal, which...

Waqf Act row: No fresh appointments or de-notification of existing waqfs, Centre assures SC

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Thursday recorded the undertaking given by the Union government that no fresh members would be appointed to waqf boards and the Central Waqf Council...

Ukraine extends martial law, general mobilisation for 90 more days

Kyiv: The Ukrainian Parliament has voted to extend the country's current martial law and general military mobilisation for another 90 days, parliament member Yaroslav Zheleznyak said on social media Telegram....

‘Concerned over violence’: SC posts further hearing on Waqf (Amendment) Act challenge pleas for tomorrow

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Wednesday expressed its concern over violence taking place amid protests against the Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025. "One thing that is very disturbing is the...

Read Previous

Swedish climate change activist Greta Thunberg attends a session at the 50th World Economic Forum (WEF) annual meeting in Davos on Tuesday. (REUTERS Photo)

Read Next

Madhya Pradesh’s Priyanshu Rajawat impresses PV Sindhu on PBL debut

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com