J&K Assembly creature of its Constitution and not Constitution of India’

By Sumit Saxena
Jan 21, 2020

New Delhi: The Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Assembly is a creature of the Constitution of the erstwhile state, and not the Constitution of India, submitted senior journalist Prem Shankar Jha’s counsel, challenging the scrapping of Article 370, before the Supreme Court on Tuesday.

Senior advocate Dinesh Dwivedi, representing Jha, told a five-judge Constitution Bench headed by Justice N.V. Ramana, that: “Legislative Assembly is one which is a creature of the Constitution of J&K and not the Constitution of India where Governor cannot be a substitute.”

He insisted that Constituent Assembly was independent of the Constitution.

“The Legislative Assembly cannot be a substitute or the successor of even the Constituent Assembly of Jammu and Kashmir,” Dwivedi.

To bolster his argument, he said that the Legislative Assembly is the creature of the Constituent Assembly of Jammu and Kashmir, which was a plenary sovereign authority unlike the Legislative Assembly.

He also added that J&K Constituent Assembly was dissolved in 1957 after the formulation of the J&K Constitution, and as a consequence, Article 370 was apparently frozen.

Dwivedi also argued that the presidential orders issued on August 5-6 are per se illegal in as much as the Constitution of Jammu and Kashmir being outside the Constitution of India. “And Article 370, it can only be repealed, ceased or suspended in the manner prescribed by the supervising law of J&K only and not otherwise. What cannot be done directly, cannot be done indirectly also,” he argued.

He insisted that these presidential orders, as they intend to apply all provisions of the Constitution of India are null and void, since they have the effect of repealing the Constitution of J&K and replacing it with “Constitution of India by an executive order”.

He emphasised that Constitutions are real codes of governance for an undefined period, and they can only be modified or amended in exercise of the self-confined amendatory powers.

Dwivedi said that Article 370 was apparently a tunnel connecting the two Constitutions, and insisted that its sole object was to ensure that people of the region have a say in their governance through their own Constitution. The senior advocate argued that Parliament could exercise few powers on the erstwhile state – alter its boundary and change the name, but cannot convert it into a Union Territory.

He also urged the court to refer the matter to a larger bench against the backdrop of two conflicting decisions – 1959 and 1970 – by a five-judge bench of the apex court on the subject. While the former recognized the temporary nature of Article 370, the latter recognises its permanence by giving the source of power to the Union, and also allows it to regulate the governing relationship between the Centre and state.

The arguments on the matter will continue on Wednesday.IANS

Supreme Court reserves verdict on pleas seeking stay on Waqf Act 2025

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Thursday reserved its order after hearing petitioners seeking a stay on the Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025 - a law vehemently defended by the government...

SC grants anticipatory bail to ex-IAS trainee officer Puja Khedkar

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Wednesday allowed the anticipatory bail plea of sacked Maharashtra cadre probationary IAS officer Puja Khedkar, who allegedly submitted false OBC and PwBD (Persons with...

Cash at judge’s residence: SC trashes plea seeking FIR against Justice Varma

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Wednesday refused to entertain a plea seeking criminal prosecution of Justice Yashwant Varma, who is embroiled in a controversy surrounding the alleged discovery of...

SC grants interim bail to Ashoka University professor arrested over remarks on Operation Sindoor

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Wednesday granted interim bail to Ali Khan Mahmudabad, a professor of political science at Haryana-based Ashoka University, who was arrested by the state police...

Ashoka University professor sent to judicial custody for 14 days

New Delhi: Ashoka University professor Ali Khan Mahmudabad on Tuesday was sent to 14-day judicial custody by a Haryana court in connection with FIRs registered against him for his allegedly...

‘Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025 designed to capture properties’, petitioners in SC

    New Delhi:  The petitioners challenging the validity of the Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025, argued before the Supreme Court on Tuesday that the contentious amendments introduced to the waqf...

Col Sofiya Qureshi remarks: SC orders formation of SIT, stays arrest of MP Minister

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Monday ordered formation of a special investigation team (SIT) to probe the charges against Madhya Pradesh Tribal Affairs Minister Vijay Shah, facing legal heat...

Ashoka University professor petitions SC challenging arrest over remarks on Operation Sindoor

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Monday agreed to urgently list a petition challenging the arrest of Ali Khan Mahmudabad, a professor of political science at Haryana-based Ashoka University, over...

Allahabad HC upholds Sambhal Jama Masjid survey order, paves way for trial to resume

Allahabad: The Allahabad High Court on Monday upheld the survey order issued by the Chandousi court for the Shahi Jama Masjid in Sambhal and dismissed the petition filed by the...

Cash at judge’s residence: SC agrees to list plea seeking FIR against Justice Varma

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Monday agreed to list for urgent hearing a plea seeking criminal prosecution of Justice Yashwant Varma, who is embroiled in a controversy surrounding the...

Nirav Modi refused bail fourth time by UK HC due to quantum of scam: ED

New Delhi: In a blow to Nirav Modi, the UK High Court has refused the fourth bail application of the alleged mastermind of $1 billion fraud against Punjab National Bank,...

ISKCON temple in Bengaluru does not belong to ISKCON Society Mumbai: SC

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Friday ruled that the ISKCON temple in Bengaluru does not belong to ISKCON Society Mumbai but to ISKCON Society Bangalore, registered under the Karnataka...

Read Previous

Swedish climate change activist Greta Thunberg attends a session at the 50th World Economic Forum (WEF) annual meeting in Davos on Tuesday. (REUTERS Photo)

Read Next

Madhya Pradesh’s Priyanshu Rajawat impresses PV Sindhu on PBL debut

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com