People–Beta, leave India to Indians,’ Naipaul was once told by mother

V.S. Naipaul at Jaipur Literature Festival in 2015.

By Saket Suman
Aug 12, 2018
New Delhi:V.S. Naipaul, known for his timeless books and unsparing views, made his last public appearance in India in January 2015 at the Jaipur Literature Festival (JLF), where he spoke at length and was even moved to tears at the overwhelming reception he got.

Recalling his maiden visit to India, the Nobel laureate had said in 2015: “I came to India first because of curiosity about my ancestral land. My publisher agreed to pay me an advance for anything I would write on India.”

But after writing two celebrated books on India, “An Area of Darkness” and “A Wounded Civilization”, his mother asked him to leave India.

“The only Hindi word my mother carried from India was ‘beta’ and she said ‘Beta, leave India to the Indians’,” he quipped.

Naipaul took part in two sessions — “A House for Mr Biswas”, which revolved around his masterpiece by the same name, and “The Writer and the World”, in which he talked about his literary journey.

Naipaul was in conversation with Farrukh Dhondy, who asked him about his life in Trinidad, the journey as a writer, his memories of India and his writings about the country.

Dhondi asked him how come he was born in Trinidad despite his deep Indian roots. Naipaul said that it had nothing to do with him.

“It had to do with my family and my parents,” he said, pointing out that there was a massive migration from India to the Caribbean islands during the middle of the 19th century and that he and his relatives “had to live with the result of that migration”.

When Dhondy proclaimed that the session would be like “a conversation between two old friends sitting with a glass of wine and looking at the sunset”, an emotional Naipaul retracted humbly: “I do not like talking about the sunset. It can be used against me to infer that I am in the sunset of my life. Unhappy metaphor.”

His wife, Lady Nadira, sat on a chair behind him, taking notes, holding the microphone when he became too tired to hold it and prompting the words when he forgot what he was saying or ran out of steam.

Naipaul also recalled the hardships during the initial days of writing.

“I was one of those people who desperately wanted to be a writer but had nothing to write about,” he said and advised young writers not be repetitive.

“Even Dickens went wrong when he began to repeat. An author should avoid doing that.”

He recognised that during the course of his long and illustrious literary journey, there had been works that he was not very proud of.

“A writer has to make a living and has to write a book. Don’t forget that.”

The last words of Naipaul on stage was a reply to a question from veteran lawyer Ram Jethmalani, who asked him the reason for calling India “An Area of Darkness” and suggested that it (India) was instead an area of light.

A humble Naipaul left a witty remark to conclude the session: “Ram is a friend and he left a very friendly comment.” Jethmalani was later seen kissing his hands and showing his reverance to the Nobel laureate.

As it turned out, Naipaul had attracted more crowd for his session than anyone else JLF hosted till 2015, more than even Amitabh Bachchan and Oprah Winfrey.

Naipual’s last visit to India will also be cherished and remembered fondly by the writing fraternity for his public reunion with Paul Theroux, with whom Naipaul shared a full-blown feud since 1996.


Shia leaders demand death for Hafiz Saeed, seek justice for 26/11 victims

Lucknow: The All India Shia Husaini Fund members have demanded justice for the 26/11 Mumbai attack victims by hanging its mastermind, Hafiz Saeed. Shia religious leaders and intellectuals from different...

Hundreds of jail police personnel go on mass CL in Gujarat

Ahmedabad: Hundreds of police personnel serving at various jails in Gujarat on Wednesday went on a mass casual leave demanding a pay hike at par with other police personnel and State...

Centre bans PFI, all its affiliates for 5 years. Here are key reasons

After two rounds of nationwide raids and arrests of over 240 members, the Centre on Wednesday banned the contentious Popular Front of India (PFI) and all its affiliates, excluding the...

Home Ministry all set to ban PFI after studying possible legal challenges

New Delhi: Days after the NIA and the ED raided several locations linked to the Popular Front of India (PFI) across the country, the Union Home Ministry is planning to...

ISI & Khalistani connections of Goldy Brar, Bishnoi

New Delhi, Sep 12 (IANS) The NIA sources have said that Goldy Brar and Lawrence Bishnoi gangs have contacts with Canada-based Khalistani elements and Pakistan-based ISI agents, and these gangs were...

IT sleuths seized our phones, cloned data, claim Oxfam, IPSMF

Days after the Income Tax Department carried out “surveys action” at their premises, Oxfam India and the Independent and Public-Spirited Media Foundation (IPSMF) alleged that the I-T personnel confiscated phones...

IS claims 1st Indian suicide bomber was Keralite Christian converted to Islam; agencies begin probe

Thiruvananthapuram: The Central intelligence agencies have commenced a probe after an article in the IS mouthpiece 'Voice of Koharasan' mentioned that 'the first Indian suicide bomber for them was a Keralite...

Hijab row not a controversy, but conspiracy against India: BJP

New Delhi: Referring to a plea in the Karnataka High Court to defer hearing on the 'hijab' row till the Assembly polls were over, the BJP has raised questions over the...

Congress to support BJP-backed Meghalaya govt

Shillong: In a significant political development, all five Congress MLAs in Meghalaya on Tuesday told Chief Minister Conrad Sangma that they wish to join the National People's Party (NPP)-led Meghalaya Democratic...

From reality to fiction, a tale of two opposites

New Delhi: Perhaps one becomes a different person after retirement? Released from the pressures and restrictions of a professional career you can give free rein to talents that remained dormant...

Ruins of ancient Sun temple in UP gets govt’s attention

Pratapgarh (Uttar Pradesh) Plans are afoot to revive a 8th century Sun temple, located in a Uttar Pradesh village in Pratapgarh district. A joint team of the state tourism department...

BHU scientist warns against ‘unscientific’ tree plantation

Varanasi: Even as Uttar Pradesh undertakes a massive tree plantation drive, a retired scientist and river engineer from the Banaras Hindu university (BHU) has warned against "unscientific plantation of trees...

Read Previous

NASA’s Parker Solar Probe lifts off successfully

Read Next

Rights–Hundreds gather in US city to oppose white supremacy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By :